A Little Girl Talk

posted by Maggie Shayne on Thursday, January 31, 2008 . Post a comment for a chance to win free books!


I have a gripe this week. Actually, I have several. And this is girl stuff, woman stuff, really. So let me just cut loose with it. Why is it that the FDA has not endorsed and insurance companies will not pay for Gardasil injections for women over twenty-six years old? Let's review. Gardasil is a huge breakthrough in women's health. It's a vaccine that prevents the four most common forms of Human Papilloma Virus (HPV), the types most likely to cause cervical cancer. But it's only approved for girls and women between the ages of nine and twenty-six. Nine and twenty-six! The reason? The only one any doctor has been able to give me is that by the time you're twenty-seven, you've probably already been exposed.

Well, I replied, doesn't that assume that a woman of twenty six is never going to have a lover she hasn't already had?
No, said the doctor I spoke with. It assumes that she's already been with enough men to ensure she's been exposed by now or is in a stable relationship and never will be at risk.

But that is a mistaken assumption! Suppose a woman has been with only one man? Suppose she married young, has been faithful, has never been exposed to HPV, and suddenly finds herself single again, at thirty, or thirty five or forty or fifty? Why should she risk contracting HPV every time she takes a new lover? Why shouldn't she be able to get the vaccine?

Well, the fact is, she can get it. She's going to have to face a thirty minute debate with her doctor first, and she's going to have to pay out of pocket for it, because insurance won't cover it. But she can get it, and she should. I have a lot of friends who are newly single and (slightly) over twenty-six. And I tell them all to insist on getting that vaccine.

To me, the medical community's assumption that a woman any older has already had every lover she's likely to have, is just ridiculous. But worse, it's discriminatory, and it's putting women's lives at risk. Marketing Gardasil to pre-teens and young adults is a fabulous idea and a great service to them. But giving the general impression that any woman older than twenty-six needn't bother, is bordering on criminal negligence. Why aren't women screaming about this?

That's gripe number one. But as long as I'm on women's health issues, here's another, and this one's for all ages. Did you know that some antibiotics will keep your birth control method from working? Someone close to me was recently put on a powerful antibiotic, Clendomicin, and was shocked to start a period despite that she's on Depo-Provera (the birth control shot.) Upon doing a little research, she learned that Clendomicin can counteract the effects of the birth control shot. She was surprised that neither the doctor who wrote, nor the pharmacist who filled the prescription had mentioned this. She was even more shocked when she scanned the drug's label and the warning sheet that came with it, and found absolutely no mention of this side effect. What responsible doctor treats a twenty-two year old woman and gives her a drug that could have this effect without a word of warning? Where is the FDA where this matter is concerned? This is something that could severely impact a woman's life, for heaven's sake. This is not a tiny matter. As I understand it, there's more than one antibiotic that can have this side effect, so women, be careful.

Women's health issues really do have a long way to go, don't they? For now, I guess all we can do is ask a ton of questions, beginning with "Are there any side effects that aren't on the label?" I strongly recommend talking to nurses. They know a lot, and the easiest way to get a straight answer without putting them too terribly on the spot, is to ask, "What would you tell your daughter or your sister, about this subject?"

To derail a bit from the topic of the moment, my big fitness week kind of petered out, for me at least. A bad bug knocked me flat on my butt for the week and some family issues kept me off balance. But I'm back on track today, so visit me on the fitness list. (See last Thursday's post for details.)

Now, do you have women's health issues you'd like to vent about? What about tips and suggestions for all your sisters out there? Post away. I'd love to hear them.

Best,
Maggie

10 Comments :

Anonymous Gabrielle said...

Interesting. I listen to Dr. Drew and he said they're close to approving the HPV vaccine to men. Let's see if there's an age limit on THEM.

And about antibiotics/birth control...I'm kinda okay with that one, simply because my mother was on the Pill and had to take antibiotics for the 'flu, and that's how I arrived in the world ;-)

7:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The medical community will eventually figure out the HPV thing. Sometimes they are slow on things.

The antibiotic/birth control interaction should have been pointed out to her by the pharmacist. That most definetly is a respsonsibility of the pharmacist. Most states have a mandatory counseling law on all new prescriptions unless the patient declines the consultation. If your state has a mandatory counseling law, the pharmacist can be reported to the State Board of Pharmacy for failure to do so.

Cheryl

8:02 AM  
Blogger Darla said...

In my opinion its not only the doctor and pharmacist that are responsible, but the person who is going to be taking the meds. Especially now a days that we have such info at our fingertips.

Lets face it, we've put doctors up on a pedastal, and are suprised when they mess up, but they are just as infallable as anyone else.

I am allergic to a med called duricef. The doctor prescribed another med to me that said if you have had a reaction to the following meds then you may also have a reaction to this one. The Dr. had my history but did not think it was a big deal. I made sure I got a different med, because I wasn't willing to chance the bad hives reaction again.

Other reactions of certain meds together are: You should not drink Grapefruit juice if you take blood pressure meds. If you are taking hormones you should not take calicum at the same time. Take one in the early in the day and the other late in the day.

As for the Gardasil injections, we should start by sending hundreds of thousands of emails to the insurance commisioner, or who would be in the best position to get the ball rolling.

8:47 AM  
Blogger Maggie Shayne said...

Darla--but the information isn't at our fingertips. I sure never would have known it. Why isn't it printed on the warning label? If the patient hadn't been a nursing student, she wouldn't have known about the interaction either.

Good point about the pharmacist/consultation law, Cheryl. Here, though, all they do is ask if you have any questions. Suppose it doesn't occur to you to ask the right one? I mean, if you don't think to ask, will this turn my hair purple, and they know it will, but don't volunteer the information unless you ask that specific question, then I think they're at fault. No layman would think of every possible question to ask.

No doubt, though, your point, that patients really do need to be careful and educated, is right on target.

Gabrielle--Excellent point about the Gardasil soon to be approved for men! I didn't even think of that angle. You can bet there will be no age limit for them (nor should there be, but there shouldn't be for us either.)

Thanks for the comments everyone!

Maggie

8:57 AM  
Blogger Amie Stuart said...

Did you know that some antibiotics will keep your birth control method from working?

FOr whatever this is worth, I'm 38 and I've known this since I was like 17 *ducks*

My tip? Get regular checkups and eat your fruits and veggies..at LEAST five a day =)It's common sense but sometimes I think we don't realize how much crap we put in our bodies.

11:18 AM  
Blogger Suzanne Forster said...

I had no clue antibiotics could knock out the birth control shots. Scary.

I also check and doublecheck anything to do with meds. I witnessed so many mistakes at every level when my mom was ill that I learned to be extra cautious, but there is more the medical community could--and should--do to alert us. And I do wonder if they're as diligent with women's issues as they should be.

Suz

1:29 PM  
Blogger Estella said...

I knew of the antibiotic thing and the Gardasil simply because my pharmacist told me about the antibiotic and I read about the Gardasil on the internet. I agree that thousnands of emails should be sent to the insurance commissioner.

1:58 PM  
Blogger Darla said...

Maggie,
Sorry, I didn't clarify...It may not be on the info that the pharmacist gives, but I did find it on the internet under the meds name under interactions.

Because of my past experiences I tend to check on the internet and read all that I can find. The doctor that prescribed the one med I didn't want to take was the same one that prescribed the one I ended up being allergic to. I believe he thought I was trying to blame him...but the truth is that I wanted it in my records and then didn't want to take a chance on going through that again. Having you body be one big hive is not something I want to do anytime soon! LOL

7:00 AM  
Blogger thea said...

More anger about this! The HPV situation needs to change, the antibiotic/birth control situation needs to change. Thank you for bringing this to our attention. I love your demeanor too! This blog is invaluable.

11:50 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Maggie, I know you mean well, however you are not a medical professional and you have given some conflicting and wrong information.

You also spelled the antibiotic Clindamycin wrong.

Please do some research on the dangers of vaccines...

3:01 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post :

Create a Link

<< Home