Stating the Obvious (Maggie)

posted by Maggie Shayne on Thursday, January 17, 2008 . Post a comment for a chance to win free books!
Link
Today the FDA has announced that over-the-counter cough and cold remedies should not be given to children under two years of age. It is expected (according to Dr. Nancy Snyderman on NBC's Today Show) that this is a first step on the way to a broader recommendation that they not be given to children under the age of 6. A logical leap would suggest the final step would be a full out ban, rather than just a recommendation. Dr. Nancy says the thing to remember is that these remedies don't cure the cold or other virus that's causing your child discomfort. All they claim to do is ease the symptoms, but studies have shown the risk of overdose is extremely high, and that the remedies often don't even do that much.

So you stop giving them. Honestly, I'd hate to think of trying to raise kids without over the counter medications, as often as mine were sick. But I guess that's just because we've become dependent on them, and have gotten a bit lazy about finding alternatives--because we haven't been forced to.

The obvious question to me is, if no one under six really needs over-the-counter medication to get over a cold, then how do we justify them for anyone else? If a six-year-old or a two-year-old or an eight-month-old can suffer through a cold without chemical help, why can't a grown up?

Good question, huh?

The answer--we can. And we probably should.

There are tons and tons of remedies that work as well as (and possibly better than) those over the counter chemical cocktails.
Tomato juice dosed with a dash of cayenne pepper, for example. Vick's Vapo-Rub, a dollop of it in a vaporizor will work wonders. For babies with croup, clap treatments every few hours. (That's where you lay the baby across your lap, face down, with her head lower than her bottom, and firmly pat the back, up and down for several minutes at a time, cupping your hand just so. It loosens the flem and congestion.)

Chicken soup actually works. They (and I don't know precisely who "they" are, but does it matter?) actually spent bucks on a study to PROVE that chicken soup works to ease cold symptoms. It has to be homemade, or so I'm told. Tea. Brandy. (Not for the kids, of course.) There are countless home remedies. Turn on the shower really hot and hold the baby in the steam that builds up in the bathroom. Warm baths and lavender scents help baby sleep. Mint helps a tummy ache. Rubbing the belly in a clockwise circular motion eases constipation.

Do you know that a cup of strong coffee can fend off an impending asthma attack, and cure a headache? Amazing, if you ask me.

Maybe if we want our kids to grow up without the risks of over-using over-the-counter meds, we should begin showing them by example. Maybe if we expect them to suffer through a cold with nothing more than ordinary, natural, home remedies, we should start doing the same. Because if we do, we'll really begin to learn which natural remedies work and which don't. We'll become experts in the field, through trial and error and our own experience. Our bodies will get tougher, learning how to deal with things we used to drug into oblivion. (Or did we just drug ourselves to the point of being unable to feel them?)

Why don't we try it for awhile and see how it goes?

And of course, the number one way to ease the symptoms of an illness, is distraction. It honestly is. Having friends over who make you laugh or just are so much fun you love seeing them can make every symptom fade to nothingness. Getting involved in a fabulous movie or book. Dragging yourself off the couch for a gentle walk, long drive, easy shopping trip, or visit to the corner coffee house are all wonderful ideas. So are soaking in a hot, scented bath, long phone conversations with loved ones, an hour spent with a favorite hobby like arranging flowers or sewing--all these things are distractions. In short, it's back to my basic and oft repeated philosophy--just reach for something that feels better. Do what gives you pleasure. Find a sense of relief, and go there, give your attention to that instead of to the problems. And the problems fade and die.

So for children, distraction can work just as well. For older kids, a favorite movie, or game or easy activity might work For younger ones, being held, rocked and cuddled is far better than lying in a crib all stuffy and feverish. Didn't you ever notice how much more they want to be held and loved when they're sick? It's because the attention makes them feel better. And snuggling is the best imaginable distraction from the illness, which is WHY it makes them feel better. And they get better faster BECAUSE they feel better.

(To get anything you want, you just practice feeling as if you already have it, and before you know it, you do! So to get over an illness, do things that make you feel better, and before you know it, you'll be better!)

I'd love to hear everyone's home remedies. We should compile a whole list of helpful suggestions for children with colds and sniffles who can no longer use over the counter meds, to help those poor moms get through what I often refer to as, "The Viral Years."

Maggie

15 Comments :

Anonymous Anonymous said...

my children have allergies and asthma. My wise pediatrician told me to avoid all over the counter remedies that were multiple drugs. She told me to use tylenol or motrin and treat the other symptoms...like vicks or popcicles or warm soup.

when one child had croup we'd wrap up and sit outside in the cold and look at the stars. i'd tell a story and we'd go back inside.

you can do the same thing with a chair in front of your open freezer door..but the stars are a special element hard to duplicate.

we also found that eating the best food you could find helped. Basic food without additives has made a BIG difference for my children.

It was interesting to watch them try things like snack packs or fake juice drinks...they'd try them once and their bodies would hate it and they'd feel uncomfortable and itch and get symptoms so we'd find them a real juice box or similiar treat and they were happy.


So I look on their allergies as a blessing..these children eat veggies and fruit and love them.

they hate processed food.

And we love vicks vabor rub and homemade soups of all kinds.

Home made bread...yum!

Rebecca

7:20 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ahh, Maggie, you sure picked a doozy this time. This is a tough one for me since I have been a mommy for almost 5 years and a pharmacist for over 17 years. I have a lot of mixed feelings on this one.

Some non-medicinal remedies work. I have advised parents to use them many times.

On the other hand, in some cases, (from personal experience) otc cold meds do work in kids. For example, when my son was only a few months old, I was giving him infant decongestant drops but I had the advantage of knowing the proper dosage and calculating it myself. Would I do it again knowing then what I know now? Yes, I would. In his case it worked. If it doesn't work, I stop giving the med and try something else.

The biggest problem with otc cold meds is that people are human. We all make mistakes. Did I measure it right? If he throws it up do I give it again? If a little worked, then more is better, right? I'll give him a dose because his dad probably forgot to give it to him. I don't need to read the directions. I'll just give what looks right. Unfortunately, if you are on the receiving end of this way of thinking, you are probably in trouble.

Knowledge is power and people need to know what exactly they are giving their kids or taking themselves. They need to ask questions. No question is ever a "dumb" question. We all need to be safe.

I could go on forever on this, taking either view. Sorry. Uh oh! Two yogurt painted faces just appeared to me. Gotta go. Life.

Cheryl

7:58 AM  
Blogger Suzanne Forster said...

Home remedies. I'm trying to remember. My mom used to wrap a Vicks-slathered sock around my neck. I hated that! Chicken soup definitely, and Ginger Ale or Seven Up for an upset stomach.

I don't think they did anything terribly exotic and I didn't either with my son. We seemed to recover pretty well on our own, as you've suggested. I still take almost no OTC meds, even for headaches. Don't know why. I just don't think about it.

Suz

8:13 AM  
Blogger Darla said...

I've always kept vicks and mentholatum on hand. We used over the counter meds, but not in excess. We were lucky with our children in that they didn't get sick much.



I think alot of the problems with kids sickness now a days is that everything is anti-bacterial, when all you really need is just plain soap and water. Let them get dirty, how is a child going to build up an ammunity if they are in a bubble. That and if you take something for every little ache, sneeze, or cough then I can see it not being a good thing and not working.

For a chronic cough that is expecially bad when you lay down: Take a tea towel with or without vicks or mentolatum, wrap and pin it around your neck. Its not really comfey but is much better then no sleep because you can't stop coughing.

Great blog Maggie.

9:39 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Kids' colds/congestion: increase fluids, use humidifier/vaporizer (doesn't matter if cold or warm---cool mist more kid friendly since don't have to worry about burns if knocked over), saline nose drops, elevate head/chest (angled wedge,pillow,etc. under mattress) while sleeping, lots of cuddle time, milk can sometimes can aggravate congestion in older children

Kids' croup: increase fluids, use vaporizer/humidifer (steam from shower works too), elevate head/chest while sleeping, cool night air for 15 to 20 minutes helps, monitor breathing while napping/sleeping, doctor prescribed steroid may be necessary, 911 is faster than driving to the ER if breathing medical emergency arises, lots of cuddle time

Kids' cough: increase fluids, constantly sip water, cough drops/hard candy to suck on, try a mixture of warm water with lemon juice and honey (adults use this with brandy instead of the lemon juice)

Kids' nausea/vomiting: flat 7-Up or coca cola, coca cola syrup, gold fish crackers, pretzels, soup, jello, dry toast,popsicles, try to avoid plain water unless very cold and only drink in small amounts (try a teaspoon to a tablespoon at a time, if child keeps it down for 15 minutes try again, and so on so forth), if vomiting persists call MD, Pinch Test for dehydration: pinch childs skin, should go back to normal but if it doesn't call 911,

Kids' diarhea: a lot of the above for vomitting, avoid dehydration, Pinch Test, call MD if it persists

Kids' fever: strip them down to underwear/diaper or to where they are comfortable, a tepid bath (not cool/cold you don't won't them to start shivering), increase fluids, use acetaminophen or ibuprofen (I like to use both, alternating for my son. My daughter's fever usually doesn't respond to apap so I just use the ibuprofen for her.)
also,high fevers can cause seizures

And don't forget about you.

Cheryl

9:41 AM  
Anonymous Cherry said...

I can just remember having a bad cough as a kid, and my great-grandmother chasing me down and shoveling a spoonful of this awful concoction of honey, whiskey (yes) and peppermint down my throat. Ack, that stuff was nasty; I'd fight her all the way. I wouldn't ever do it to my kid, but it worked! =)

10:20 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Honey not for kids under 1 year.

c

11:08 AM  
Blogger Maggie Shayne said...

You guys have great suggestions! Keep them coming.

Maggie

11:22 AM  
Blogger Estella said...

I remember being fed onion syrup for a cold with a cough. Onion, sugar and a small amount of water boiled together. Nasty tasting, but effective.

1:35 PM  
Blogger Tara Taylor Quinn said...

My daughter was twenty before she ever took an antibiotic - and that was when she had her wisdom teeth removed. We never used over the counter stuff for her because the taste gagged her. Could hardly get her to chew children's vitamins! I'm a firm believer in keeping the body pure from substances that, while helping some symptoms, interfere with other processes. Of course, I absolutely have to add that it's easy for me to say this as other than colds and occasional stomach upsets, we were healthy all those years.

Last year, at twenty-one, my daughter had strep throat worse than anything I'd ever seen. I put off going to the doctor, thinking that, as always, it would clear itself up if she'd slow down and get much needed rest. It didn't. She almost suffocated when her throat swelled with infection. I took her in. Gave her the presribed antibiotics and the anti-vomiting meds needed to keep down the antibiotics. But the only thing that seemed to work was the hot tea and honey I made her float away in for the eight days it took her to recover. This year, when the sore throat started to come back, she started in immediately with the tea and she reported within a couple of days that she was doing much better.

1:43 PM  
Blogger Ranurgis said...

One thing I've found that has helped me a lot is taking regular doses of Vitamin C. While I was doing that, I had only one cold in over 20 years, though it didn't prevent a nasty triple infection one Christmas but that might have been because I was just way too busy to take my vitamin Cs. I'm now back to taking 500 to 1000mg/day (sometimes a little more) as a chewable tablet.

I read about that study on chicken soup too.

I also hate processed food. Not long after I got back from Europe, I had a processed cheese slice. It was so full of salt/preservative that I said: never again. There are also some very touted fruit juices that I just can't handle. That's why I stick to the tablets for my Vitamin C.

Fortunately, I have a doctor too who isn't eager to give me medication for everything. Except for the time of infections that I mentioned, he's hasn't given me any antibiotics for the last 20 years--certainly not for colds or viruses.

Yep, those old home remedies work most of the time. I guess we always want a quick fix to everything. Sometimes we've actually gotten it only to realize years later what those "quick fixes" ended up doing to us.

Ginger ale and 7up are some of my favorites for upset stomach or nausea too. The Chinese sailors apparently used to eat ginger to keep from getting seasick. So as soon as I feel nauseated, I reach for some ginger: ginger ale, tablet or ginger pieces to help me feel better. And it always works, though sometimes a little slowly.

8:27 PM  
Blogger Ranurgis said...

Oh, and I must remember that one about a mentholated towel. That's what my mother always used to give us too for the day and night when we had coughs. I haven't thought of that for a long time.

Thanks to whoever mentioned it.

8:29 PM  
Blogger Ranurgis said...

How about onion and honey instead of sugar? That might be even healthier. I know my grandfather swore by that for coughs. But it's true, it is a little awful. LOL

8:34 PM  
Blogger deseng said...

Yes I definitely agree homemade chicken noodle soup is the best for colds. I add all kinds of good vegetable like carrots, celery, along with real cloves of garlic, minced. The garlic is supposed to be really good for you.

I also drink lot's of tea with honey and lemon. The best when you have a sore throat because it coats it.

Also, I take zinc tablets, echinaccea, and vit. C when I feel a cold coming on. It always helps to fight the cold. Plus the biggest thing I think is a really sound, deep sleep. I try to get close to 9 hours of sleep when I start feeling sick. I usually always beat my sickness if I do that.

Also, during a cold I boil some hot water on the stove and let steam in the air of my house. Then, at night I take the boiling pot of water into my bedroom, place it on a good pot holder or trivet, immediately close the bedroom door and let the steam fill the room. It really helps to open the nasal passages so you can get a good nights sleep.

Those are my tried and true remedies for a cold. Also, I like the ricoli herbal sugar-free cough drops, and fisherman's friends cough drops when I have a cold or sore throat.

7:59 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

My mother-in-law was awsome for this. She had a recipe for everything. For that dry hacking cough we used equal amounts of honey, lemon juice and glycerin. Teaspoon of that and they shut up for the night. For pink eye we used a teabag as warm as you could stand it and apply until cool. I wrestled with the kids when they were in kindergarden once with that rotten salve and she laughed at me and told me about the teabag. That teabag can be pretty handy too, we used it for sunburns on the face too.

7:35 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post :

Create a Link

<< Home