Mourning the Missing (Patricia Potter)

posted by Patricia Potter on Friday, June 26, 2009 . Post a comment for a chance to win free books! It's easy! Either sign in or click anonymous and post!
Ah, I don’t know if it’s the years creeping up, or nostalgia or simply frustration with today’s ever shrinking books, but I’m mourning today for yesterday’s music and yesterday’s books.

I yearn for more memorable love songs. Noise seems to have replaced melody, and yelling singing. But most of all, I miss the old epic novels that often stretched through a character’s lifetime.

We have some amazing writers today, but the publishers are pushing to make books ever shorter. Some of it is cost of paper. Some of it is marketing (they want to put five books deep on a shelf, not two). Some of it is the publishers’ perception that today’s readers have neither the time or patience to read larger books. I think Diana Gabaldon’s ‘The Outlander” was probably the last really big book I’ve seen in recent years. Oops, and, of course, Harry Potter, but he’s unique.

What has happen to those big juicy sagas and novels that used to dominate the best seller lists. Books like “Lonesome Dove,” the James Michener’s history/fiction epics (“Hawaii,” “Texas,” and “Centennial” to name a few).” Women’s books like “Forever Amber.” Romances like Celeste de Blasis’s 700-page “The Proud Breed" (My alltime favorite book by the way).” The latter is the only book that drew my tears at the end, and that’s because I had lived the heroine’s entire adult life with her. And then, of course, there’s “Gone With The Wind.”

I was reminded of how much I missed those richly drawn books when I recently ordered Kathleen Windsor’s “Wanderers Eastward, Wanderers West” and Anya Seton’s “Devil Water.” (All of Anya Seton’s books have been recently reissued in trade paperback). The former is a big sprawling epic of some 900 pages, at least I remember it as a grand epic. I read it some fifty years ago and saw it mentioned somewhere. I checked Amazon and, of course, they had an old copy. I’m saving it for a time I have a week or two of uncluttered time (it will probably never happen), but it does my heart good to look at it and dream.

I miss savoring the texture of the longer novel, the time to really get to know the characters, to become as one with them. I hate it when I fall in love with characters and they leave me all too quickly. I love starting a long book and knowing I have days and days of pleasure to look toward, not just a few hours.

I know we don’t have the time that people used to have to read. We have so many more distractions: television, internet, social networking, electronic games and the miraculous new I-phone that can do any and every thing. Men are working longer. Women work all day and come home to more work. Maybe they have time for a few pages before bed. Maybe not.

But as more publishers urge their authors, including myself, to write shorter and shorter books, I feel I'm cheating my readers. I fear we are losing the complete immersion into a time and place. I'm afraid we don't have space to develop richly textured backgrounds and characterization. As publishers continue this trend, we’ll probably end with all 100-page books.

Do you miss those grand epics, too, or do you just not have the time to savor them today? Have you noticed that books are getting shorter? Do you prefer them or do you hope, as I do, for a longer read. Not always, of course, but definitely as part of my reading menu. And do you have a book that lingers in your thoughts?

7 Comments :

Blogger Jenny said...

Two things killed the big book:

1. Paper costs. They rose dramatically in the 90s making large books much more expensive to print. The shift to using POD for first run mainstream books (Expresso book machine) will put even more pressure on publishers to keep pages low.

2. Proliferation of Sales Venues. Outlander was published when Waldenbooks and B Dalton were "the chains" and there were far book fewer stores and outlets sending back returns. When the superstores expanded in the mid 90s it greatly increased the books displayed, but also the books returned.

Combine the cost of paper with increased returns and you see why publishers avoid large books whenever possible.

Beyond that, the idea of having popular authors release 2 books a year would have horrified publishers in 1990. Now it is becoming standard. Very few authors can write a well researched, complexly plotted 700 page book in 4 months.

5:07 AM  
Blogger Patricia Potter said...

Jenny. . . Great observations. I knew of course about paper costs, but I hadn't considered the change of venues, and I should have. Thanks for responding.

8:04 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Pat,

What I read depends on my mood. I like both long books and short. It's funny that you mention Diane Gabaldon's series because I'm currently reading it. I read the first four books years ago, when they were new. But I have not read her more recent ones, so decided to go back and start from the beginning. They are truly amazing pieces of art. Another "series" I've sunk my teeth into are Stephen King's Gunslinger books (which I also want to go back and read all over again) and his "The Stand."

There times, though, when I want a good, fast, gripping read of only 200-300 pages. I tend to NOT like really short things (100-200).

My feeling is that if a writer truly has something to say that can/will fill volumes, there's always a way to get it out to the public. Perhaps we just have to be more sly about it these days.

Okay, so I've been wanting to share this is with some "real" writers for three weeks and I can't stand it anymore: I finally finished the first complete draft of my first book! It's tucked away, for the time being, while I start the process of finding an agent. Then I'll take it out again and fix some things I already know need tweaking. I thought I'd never get it done! The second one is already started, too......it's an amazing feeling!!!!!!!!

robyn in iowa

1:12 AM  
Blogger Sue G said...

I agree with the "mood" comment, but I, too miss the epics. Celeste DeBlasis, miss her too. My favorites by her include The Proud Breed and the Swan Trilogy.

I think the cost of paper is kind of a cop out for the publishing world. It's not like the cost of books didn't skyrocket before the paper costs increased. Some of us like real books as opposed to kindle; I cannot imagine not being able to turn a real page.

I think like the 89 minute movie, "someone" decided that people always want fast. As a kid, I remember 2 hour movies were pretty short ones, there were intermissions in the longer movies. Yes, life is busy, but...fast food isn't always what everyone wants. The powers that be need to realize that we're not all the same. You can't always tell a story in 150 pages or 89 minutes. I also think with the price of books, I'd rather spend money on one that I can read for more than 2 hours. Though I just buy what I like, regardless of length.

Sue

11:38 AM  
Blogger Patricia Potter said...

Robyn. . .

Sorry I didn't get back to you yesterday but there were several famly birthdays.
BUT. . . a huge congratulations on finishing that book. It's a great achievement. Wishing you much success with it.

2:34 PM  
Blogger Darla said...

I'm not realy keen on really short books, I don't feel like it really gives one enough to go on. Thats one of the reasons I love series, you get to know more.

I love the feel of a real book in my hand, but I have so many I just plain don't have the room any more...even after giving up almost a 1,000 of them. The kindle lets me keep what I've still got while getting more!

Robyn...I'm not a writer at all, but I'd like to tell you Congratulations and wish you the best on your way to getting published! Good Luck! BG!

5:22 AM  
Blogger Nana/Mom said...

Hi All,

Robyn-congratluations!!!!!!!!!!!!
You are a far brave soul than I.

I LOVE big long books, and series, and short ones too. Depends on what I NEED in reading. The shorter books I have always looked at as "candy", or "treats". Sometimes I just like a quick short read that is fun. But having said that, I love to sink my teeth into a good juicy story. I too love the outlander series, and Harry Potter. The Earth Childrens series by Jean Auel is also awesome (well, till the most recent Shelters of Stone, a little dissapointing).

Good series stories work for me too. Maggie's vamp's are a perfect example. I sometimes will get 2 or 3 in a row, and just read them one after the other. Now that is fun.

Regarding venues, there are fewer of everything, and all is more expensive to do. Paperbook prices rose long befor the current $ crunch.

Thanks Patricia for a great blog.

Patsi

5:50 AM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post :

Create a Link

<< Home